AI Regulation Set to Reshape Cyber Insurance Risk and Coverage

Cyber Insurance Must Monitor AI Regulation Closely

The surge in AI-related regulations is poised to increase risks for buyers of cyber insurance and their carriers. Across the U.S., nearly half of the states have already proposed or enacted AI governance laws. Colorado leads with the Colorado Artificial Intelligence Act, set to take effect in February 2026, marking the first comprehensive state-level AI regulation.

This legislation will likely influence other states as they draft similar laws. Its focus is on high-risk AI systems that impact critical areas like employment, finance, healthcare, housing, and insurance. The law assigns clear responsibilities to both AI developers and deployers, aiming to prevent algorithmic discrimination.

Key Provisions of the Colorado AI Act

• AI developers must manage known or foreseeable risks and report incidents of algorithmic discrimination within 90 days to the state attorney general and deployers.
• Deployers must exercise reasonable care, conduct regular risk assessments, implement risk management programs, provide appeal mechanisms for individuals, and meet reporting obligations.

Other states are considering bills covering consumer protections against AI profiling, AI use in hiring, deepfake regulations, and the creation of AI task forces. These efforts resemble the path taken by recent data privacy laws across the U.S.

Federal and International AI Regulatory Trends

Congress has introduced over 100 AI-related bills, focusing primarily on transparency and accountability to protect consumers. Some bills target specific industries such as healthcare, marketing, and education. Meanwhile, the Federal Trade Commission emphasizes clear AI documentation and obtaining consumer consent in its guidelines.

At the technical standards level, the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) remains central in developing AI governance frameworks, including privacy-enhancing technology guidelines.

Internationally, the EU AI Act stands out as one of the few comprehensive AI laws, setting a global reference point by categorizing AI systems by risk level and imposing corresponding obligations. The EU's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) also influences AI governance worldwide, with many countries adapting existing laws to address AI. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has established principles emphasizing transparency, accountability, and human rights, guiding member countries in regulation development.

Emerging Risks for Cyber Insurers From AI

AI is already contributing to losses in the cyber insurance market. Litigation related to AI exceeds 200 claims in courts, highlighting the rising risk. One significant concern is data bias, where AI unintentionally discriminates against certain demographic groups. Because AI acts as an agent of the organization, companies may face discrimination lawsuits, including potential class actions.

The impact of AI-related risks extends beyond cyber insurance. Policies like tech errors and omissions (E&O), employment practices liability, product liability, medical malpractice, and directors & officers (D&O) insurance may also be affected.

For example, a product liability claim could arise if a manufacturer uses AI in production and the end product is defective. This means risk managers must adopt a broad perspective when addressing AI risks, implementing strict policies on AI usage, access controls, and integration into overall data governance.

Cyber Insurance Underwriting and AI

Currently, cyber insurers are in the early stages of adjusting underwriting practices for AI risks. While cybersecurity controls such as multi-factor authentication, backups, and patch management remain top priorities, questions about AI usage are starting to appear and will likely increase over time.

Potential Changes in Coverage for AI-Related Risks

As AI regulations evolve, organizations might find it harder to secure cyber insurance coverage for regulatory claims tied to AI. Insurers may need to revise coverage terms to address risks like algorithmic discrimination and failures in high-risk AI systems.

Some carriers have already updated policy language to limit or exclude coverage for costs related to regulatory investigations, lawsuits, settlements, and fines arising from AI incidents. Liability determination between AI developers and deployers could also influence claims processing.

Policies could evolve to cover expenses related to compliance activities, such as AI risk assessments and required reporting, reflecting the growing regulatory focus on AI governance.

For insurance and marketing professionals, staying informed about these regulatory changes and how they affect risk management and coverage is essential. Developing expertise in AI risks and compliance can offer a competitive edge in advising clients or managing corporate policies.

To enhance your understanding of AI’s impact on industries and risk, explore comprehensive AI training options at Complete AI Training.