Air's CEO Is Betting $70 Million That AI Won't Replace Creatives
Shane Hegde published a handwritten letter in the New York Times on March 22 and listed his personal cell number at the bottom. He invited anyone who disagreed with him to call.
His position: AI will never replace creative professionals.
This is a man who has raised $70 million to build AI tools for creative teams. Nearly all of Air's product resources have shifted toward AI-centric features. His best engineers spend most of their days evaluating AI-written code. So the letter was either a bold statement of genuine belief or an exceptionally well-timed piece of marketing. Probably both.
What the Letter Actually Says
Hegde's central argument: machines find patterns and recommend the most common answer. They are always correct, but not always right.
He defends creative inefficiency-the doubt, indecision, and what he calls "cancerous reflection" at 9AM on a street corner that actually leads to great work. Machines don't do that. One line stuck: "AI would never smoke a cigarette with you."
Another: "The organizations that survive will require human beings who are willing to take risks. These people understand that letting what they love kill them is a uniquely human trait."
The Real Problem Creatives Face
Creative professionals aren't debating philosophy. They're watching copywriter job postings dry up. Design briefs are going to Midjourney. Freelancers who made $80,000 two years ago are making $55,000 now.
But here's what Hegde noticed eight years ago: the demand for creative and content skills hasn't collapsed. It's moved. Tech companies are hiring people who think and write like journalists in increasing numbers.
"Every company was becoming a media company," he wrote in the letter. "And, if true, every company would need an engine to scale their creative work."
How Air Says It's Different
Hegde came up through finance, not creative work. He co-founded Air in 2017 on the thesis that companies need tools to scale creative output efficiently.
When asked what he'd say to a freelancer who lost income to AI in the last year, Hegde said: "The part that will never go away is the thing that got them their job in the first place. The judgment and nuance will always be needed and that's something AI can never automate or replace."
Air positions itself as removing the logistics-collecting files, approvals, resizing, organizing. The busywork. Not the actual creative work.
What he doesn't say, and what nobody in this space says cleanly, is what happens after the busywork disappears. That decision lives with whoever controls the budget.
The Harder Questions
On automating creative decisions: A big part of what a creative director gets paid for is knowing when to break the guidelines, when the vibe is off even if the hex codes are right. Hegde said the creative director will still "want to come in and get their hands dirty on something and tweak it and change it and that might not mean chatting with a machine."
Most founders don't build an off-ramp away from their own product into the answer. That one does.
On who benefits: Well-funded startups have promised to empower creatives, then pivoted to selling to the companies that used to hire them. Hegde said Air believes "humans are, and will forever be, in the loop for this magical zero-to-one moment in the creative process."
The question his letter raises, and that this interview circles without fully settling, is who captures the upside when you automate the logistics of creative work. Hegde thinks it's the creative professional or at least the companies that allow them to do their thing.
The market will have its own answer eventually.
What Stands Out
Hegde's argument stays consistent: AI handles the operational layer. Humans own the judgment layer. The two don't substitute for each other.
It's a cleaner position than most people in this space are willing to commit to publicly, which is probably why the New York Times letter got traction.
For what it's worth, his cell number is still at the bottom of the letter.
Learn more about AI for Creatives and how these tools are reshaping creative work across industries.
Your membership also unlocks:
