Complete AI Training
Start for Free

Your job's AI kit

Get your AI kit

Tell us who you are and what you do. We show you your kit right away and email you the link: skills, prompts, AI agents, MCP servers and courses for your job.

500+ jobs ready, and we make a kit for any other job. No payment needed to look.

Share

AI news ·

Former travel writers test AI trip planning across France, find it 80% accurate on big decisions but unreliable on details

Two former travel writers tested AI trip planning across France and found it about 80% accurate. Gemini and Perplexity nailed the route and cities but got hours, menus, and one wine tasting completely wrong.

Former Travel Writers Test AI on France Trip, Find It 80% Accurate

Two former travel writers who left the industry over AI content flooding search results have completed a deliberate experiment: they let AI plan an entire trip across France, then graded what worked and what failed.

Amber and Eric Hoffman, who spent more than a decade writing about food and travel for publications and tourism boards, used Gemini and Perplexity in parallel to plan a multi-city route through France. The tools independently recommended the same itinerary: Bordeaux, La Rochelle, and Nantes, with a day trip to Clisson.

The result was roughly 80% accurate - strong on major decisions, unreliable on specifics.

Where AI Excelled

Both tools selected a country the Hoffmans didn't know well, sequenced three cities logically, and identified a workable train route between them. The recommendations surfaced La Rochelle, a port town neither the Hoffmans nor their well-traveled friends had considered before.

Restaurant recommendations landed roughly 80% of the time. AI directed them to a Bordeaux food market they returned to three days in a row.

"AI was excellent at the big decisions and unreliable on the details," Amber Hoffman said. "It chose the right country, cities, and route - then sent us to a wine tasting that didn't exist."

Where It Failed

Hours and menu details were frequently wrong. When asked to replicate the open-air market dining experience they found in Bordeaux at other stops, AI recommendations missed the mark.

One specific failure: AI suggested a wine tasting that had no actual existence. The tools couldn't grasp nuance or understand how to adapt a successful experience from one city to another.

What This Means for Travel Writers

The Hoffmans see a clear division of labor emerging. AI now handles the structural work - route planning, identifying destinations, basic restaurant discovery. Travelers still need to verify details themselves before booking.

For travel content creators, the implication is direct: AI will absorb logistics and listicles. First-hand storytelling and lived experience become more valuable, not less.

Amber Hoffman, who also consults with companies on AI visibility, approached the experiment as both traveler and researcher - testing not just whether AI could plan a trip, but how accurately it surfaces real-world hospitality businesses.

The full account of what AI got right and wrong across all four destinations is published on Food & Drink Destinations.

For AI for Writers, this experiment offers a practical case study in how generative tools perform on research and verification tasks - core skills for anyone writing about real-world subjects.

Share