Unions Struggle to Protect Journalists as AI Spreads Through Newsrooms
Journalists across the United States, Greece, and the Philippines are pushing back against AI tools their employers are deploying without consent or disclosure. Union leaders say the technology is moving faster than their ability to negotiate protections, creating a cat-and-mouse game they're losing.
The immediate threat isn't mass layoffs. Around two-thirds of media managers surveyed by the Reuters Institute said they haven't cut jobs because of AI. But changes are happening in other ways. The Associated Press offered buyouts to more than 120 staff members as it pivoted toward AI and video production.
At three newspapers owned by McClatchy-the Miami Herald, The Sacramento Bee, and The Kansas City Star-unions filed grievances over a content-scaling system. The tool generates summaries, creates audience-specific versions of stories, and produces video scripts from reporters' work. Stories appear under journalists' bylines with no disclosure that AI was involved.
"We don't want the public to think we have anything to do with it," said Ariane Lange, an investigative reporter at the Sacramento Bee. "We think it's a betrayal of the public's trust, and it undermines our credibility."
What Unions Are Negotiating
Collective bargaining agreements have started to address AI. Some unions, like the News Media Guild, include language preventing AI from displacing staff. Others, such as the PEN Guild, mandate higher severance if layoffs are AI-related.
But job protection is only part of the battle. Tony Winton, chief administrative officer of the News Media Guild, which represents newsrooms including the Associated Press and The Guardian, said the harder issue is determining which uses of AI are acceptable.
"We have an active working group of members who want to expand this conversation with the AP," Winton said. "The contract language we have is good. But as more and more uses are being found for the technology, we need to have a conversation."
Unions are raising concerns about journalistic accuracy. AI systems have documented problems with fabrication. When inaccurate content appears under a journalist's name, it damages both the publication's credibility and the reporter's reputation.
At Politico, the PEN Guild discovered that management deployed two AI initiatives without advance notice or negotiation-one generated coverage of the Democratic National Convention, the other automatically produced reports through a deal with Capital AI. The union's contract required management to warn the union and negotiate before using AI in ways that meaningfully affect employees' work.
Ariel Wittenberg, a public health reporter and unit chair of PEN Guild, said the deployments violated the contract because they didn't follow the publication's journalism ethics standards or ensure human oversight.
A Global Challenge
Journalists in countries outside the United States face steeper obstacles. In the Philippines, most newsrooms lack formal unions with bargaining power. The National Union of Journalists of the Philippines does advocacy work but cannot enforce protections through contracts.
A newsroom manager and union director in the Philippines, speaking anonymously, called AI "an existential threat." Most newsrooms there have only vague provisions about using AI responsibly, with no explicit protections against replacing journalists with the technology.
"My hope is that at some point [managers] will realize it and then we will have to adjust our policies on it," he said.
In Greece, the Panhellenic Federation of Journalists' Union moved ahead of the curve. In 2025, they launched a code of ethics adopted by five unions in the federation. Union president Sotiris Triantafyllou said managers and media owners have agreed to protect journalists, though he acknowledged uncertainty about the future.
The Core Disagreement
Union representatives across countries agree on one principle: AI should not automate skilled journalistic work. They support using AI for "housekeeping" tasks like transcription, translation, and summarizing large datasets.
The pushback comes when managers use AI to generate content, rewrite stories, or create coverage without human judgment. Wittenberg said some newsrooms have lost sight of why audiences trust them.
"In the rush to innovate, news organizations think they are competing with tech companies," she said. "The reality is that we are still news organizations and that means that we have an obligation to our ethics and to give our readers accurate factual news."
Some publishers are aggressively scaling output with AI. U.K. local news publisher Mediahuis uses AI-assisted reporters. Fortune editor Nick Lichtenberg recently faced scrutiny after producing more than 600 stories with AI assistance.
A Moving Target
Union negotiators face a problem that keeps changing. First came the question: Will AI replace my job? Now they're grappling with dozens of others. If an employer sells journalistic content to train an AI model, should employees who produced that content be compensated? Will using AI be optional or mandatory? Who provides training?
"It's like nailing Jell-O to a wall, because you think you've got something done, and then the technology changes again," Winton said.
The newsroom manager from the Philippines said journalists should accept that AI writing in journalism is inevitable. Economic pressure will push newsrooms to adopt it, even as the technology threatens human creativity and editorial craft.
"It's sad and tragic in a lot of ways, and many of us are mourning the kind of journalism we are used to, but the reality is ChatGPT, Gemini, and others are already capable of replicating the way humans speak and write," he said.
Unions have won some victories. They've negotiated proactively with management in Greece and secured binding arbitration in the United States. But the Philippines source said the battle will be difficult because the news industry largely regulates itself and media owners lack incentive to impose strict protections.
"As journalists, we have to be prepared because this is going to be an uphill battle," he said.
For writers concerned about how AI affects your work, understanding AI for Writers and the underlying technology of Generative AI and LLM can help you navigate these changes in your own career.
Your membership also unlocks:
