An AI-generated actress is set to make its film debut in the upcoming feature Misaligned, a collaboration between directors, producers, writers, and AI specialists. When the project was announced in July 2026, it drew immediate backlash from audiences and artists alike, with SAG-AFTRA - the entertainment industry's largest labor union - stating that using AI in place of real performers directly harms creatives.
The controversy extends back years, driven by the tension between preserving creativity as technology evolves and the deep impact these developments have on artists. The union's members went on a 110-day strike in 2021 over concerns that production companies had no clear system for how AI would be used.
CGI vs. AI: Two different tools
Computer-generated imagery and technological special effects have been part of filmmaking since the 1950s and 1960s, after being invented for the military before being adapted for cinema. Today, visual effects is one of the fastest-growing sectors in entertainment, with an annual growth rate of around 10 percent.
But CGI and VFX remain deeply human-dependent. Technicians spend large portions of their jobs manipulating tiny pixel elements to create something new, and in some instances, a single effect can take years to produce. Hundreds of people may be involved in creating one visual effect for a single scene.
"With CGI, there's a more human quality, because it's going to make mistakes. It's going to be exactly what the author wants," said Sofia Dodge, a senior at Casa Grande high school.
AI works differently. Its process is formulaic, doesn't rely on heavy human intervention, and is significantly faster and cheaper than VFX. After OpenAI and ChatGPT went public in 2022, many parts of the film and television industry began adopting AI for these reasons. It's already being used for tasks like digitally replacing a character's face, de-aging actors, subtitling, and translation.
Some directors, including Christopher Nolan, reject the technology entirely and rely on practical effects. But the distinction between CGI and AI matters most when considering employment and artistic choice. CGI and VFX depend on artists, animators, technicians, and filmmakers to create a cohesive piece. AI, with the exception of a human providing a prompt, can produce essentially every other aspect of the work itself.
The creativity question
Art has often been considered something that reflects human experience, whether realistic or fantastical. Replacing human creators with the work of a fake human takes away jobs, creativity, and artistry in the form of high cost and convenience.
"(AI) suddenly takes away all the potential to be creative and replaces it with perfection that isn't human," said Twyla Sheridan, a Berkeley High School sophomore.
"There may absolutely be public benefits (to AI) but it is hard for me to see how AI will not reduce the number of jobs of people who make a living making movies," said Oslo Gudon, a Berkeley High junior.
Technological advancement has created new creative opportunities in entertainment, including roles for technical engineers, animators, and other visual effects work that extends into nearly every aspect of filmmaking. The question is whether AI represents a similar expansion - or a replacement. For those working in creative fields, the distinction is worth tracking closely. Generative Video Courses and AI for Creatives resources can help artists understand the tools being adopted by studios, and where human skills still fit into the pipeline.
Why this matters for creatives
The film industry is not yet at the point where AI is responsible for creating entire films, but it is slowly being brought into the process. For working creatives, the practical takeaway is to know which parts of your workflow involve irreplaceable human judgment - and which parts a studio might see as a cost to cut. The SAG-AFTRA strike and the Misaligned backlash show that audiences and unions are pushing back, but the pressure to adopt cheaper, faster AI tools is not going away.
Your membership also unlocks:
