ServiceNow's AI Agents Expose Competing Priorities Between HR and IT
ServiceNow introduced new AI agents at its Knowledge 2026 conference this week that can execute tasks across departments and software systems. The company unveiled Autonomous CRM tools and expanded its EmployeeWorks product, which debuted last fall, to handle HR requests through AI.
But the rollout revealed a fundamental tension: what works for IT departments doesn't necessarily work for HR.
Different Goals, Different Risks
CVS Health, a ServiceNow customer, illustrated the divide during a conference session. The company deployed EmployeeWorks to create a single entry point for employee queries across HR, IT, procurement, store operations and other units.
"We all wanted different things," Joe Lombardi, associate vice president of digital workplace at CVS Health, said. "IT wanted call deflection. HR wanted quality answers that were accurate."
The distinction matters because the stakes differ. When an IT agent makes a mistake, employees file a follow-up ticket. When an HR agent gets something wrong - especially on compliance or benefits - the consequences can be severe.
Lisa Highfield, principal director at HR research firm McLean & Co., said shared platforms create a false equivalence between IT and HR use cases. "When an HR agent gets a critical issue wrong, you may have a compliance issue or a damaged employee relationship," she said.
Compliance Concerns Outweigh Speed
Analysts said HR teams face legal and regulatory risks that IT departments typically don't. Evelyn McMullen, an analyst at Nucleus Research, said HR should ask whether they should deploy an AI agent for a task, not just whether they can.
"Agentic AI has brought forth a fear of the unknown on multiple fronts, including compliance and security risk, and end-user job security concerns," McMullen said. "No organization wants to be made an example of how not to deploy AI."
ServiceNow framed its HR announcements around connecting agents across systems to handle multi-step processes. A simple employee name change, for example, requires updates across multiple databases - work the agents are designed to automate.
The company plans to release HR Business Partner Experience tools and next-generation manager tools later this year to automate administrative work and surface talent insights.
The Productivity Question
Holger Mueller, vice president at Constellation Research, said low-risk HR processes are ready for automation now. These include employee self-service tasks like checking vacation balances and approving timesheets.
Automating these tasks removes work from HR professionals. "If they can do that with agents - that takes away the HR pro," Mueller said.
Data backs this up. The Society for Human Resource Management reported HR staffing ratios dropped from 1.98 HR professionals per 100 employees in 2025 to 1.67 in 2026 - a 16% decline. SHRM said it has heard anecdotally that organizations are using AI to automate HR tasks, though the organization doesn't have formal data on the reasons for the drop.
Recruiting has seen the highest AI adoption in HR functions at 27%, suggesting job cuts may be concentrated there.
The Irrelevance Risk
Gartner analysts are warning HR leaders about a different risk: being sidelined entirely. If IT drives HR transformation efforts while HR moves slowly on AI, HR departments risk losing strategic influence.
"The risk isn't just falling behind competitors - it's becoming irrelevant," Gartner analyst Hanne Nieberg wrote. "As AI augments 100% and performs up to 50% of current HR tasks, organizations that don't adapt their operating model will face declining productivity, diminishing strategic influence and the inability to attract top talent."
ServiceNow itself is seeing efficiency gains. The company said AI now resolves support cases in less than 20 minutes compared to the typical two-day human resolution time. Despite 19% year-over-year subscription revenue growth, ServiceNow kept headcount flat.
For HR departments, the challenge is clear: move forward on AI adoption while managing compliance risks, or risk becoming obsolete.
Learn more: AI for CHROs (Chief Human Resources Officers) covers strategic adoption, compliance concerns, and workforce transformation for HR leaders.
Your membership also unlocks:
